Table of Contents
Is conscription a good idea?
Conscription provides an important reminder of what it means to be a citizen in a liberal democracy. The return of conscription would revitalize the weakening civil-military link and remind people of their civil obligations. National service is an important way to instill common values and build character.
Why is conscription not good?
One downside of conscription is that the time in the military can be quite hard. For many people, it is the first time away from home for a longer period of time and they might not be mentally prepared for this. Some people may feel quite lonely and may also not be able to deal with the strict rules in the military.
Why is conscription necessary?
Conscription was necessary because it was needed to win the war. With the lack of men in the battlefield, the front would not be able to hold off German attacks. They would not be able to replace the wounded or dead soldiers and as a result they will lose their positions (ref.
How did conscription affect Australia?
At the outbreak of the First World War, the number of people volunteering to enlist for the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) was so high that recruitment officers were forced to turn people away. As the war went on, casualty rates increased and the number of volunteers declined. By 1916 the AIF faced a shortage of men.
Why do countries have conscription?
However, for much of U.S. history the nation required young men to serve in the military, both for emergency wartime drafts and in peace time through a process known as standing conscription. Standing conscription ensured the military had enough personnel to counter threats.
Why was conscription introduced?
The government saw no alternative but to increase numbers by conscription – compulsory active service. Parliament was deeply divided but recognised that because of the imminent collapse of the morale of the French army, immediate action was essential. In January 1916 the Military Service Act was passed.
Why is military conscription good?
Military service can provide people with useful vocational skills. Serving in the armed forces means more than knowing how to pick up a gun and how to use it. Military life can teach people specific technical skills that they can use throughout their life.
What do you think about conscription?
Conscription is involuntary servitude. It is forced labor. It is immoral. One does not owe military service to the state. All the benefits we get from the state is already paid for in taxes, nothing is free.
Is military conscription ever justified?
Conscription is never justified, not even in a just war. It is involuntary servitude. It is forced labor. It is immoral. One does not owe military service to the state. All the benefits we get from the state is already paid for in taxes, nothing is free.
Is conscription a form of forced labor?
It is forced labor. It is immoral. One does not owe military service to the state. All the benefits we get from the state is already paid for in taxes, nothing is free. Conscription is not the same as taxation. In conscription, one is forced to do a job that he/she does not agree with.
When was conscription introduced in the UK?
The conscription debate raged through most of 1917 and into 1918. The required legislation, the Military Service Act, worked its way through Parliament during the summer to be passed in late August.