How can an indifferent act become morally good or morally evil?

How can an indifferent act become morally good or morally evil?

Thus even though the act considered in itself (i.e., from its object) is indifferent, it is either good or evil from the end and circumstances; for no act is performed except for some end or reason, and this is either good or evil. Hence no individual human act is indifferent.

How will you know if an action is good or evil or indifferent?

The dictionary defines it by saying “the action of regarding something as being caused by a person or thing.” There are actions, their consequences, and the society’s perception. If our actions are for the benefit of others, then they are good. However, if they are harmful to any, they’re bad.

What does indifference to morality mean?

consists in having some kind of pro- or con-attitude rather. than in accepting some proposition that can be assessed as. true or false. The thesis that it is a necessary condition of. believing an act to be morally wrong that one have some.

How can an act be indifferent?

An indifferent act is any action that is neither good nor evil. When acts are considered in general, with respect only to their object, there are acts that can be said to be neither good nor bad, but indifferent.

How can you say that an act is morally good?

A human act is moral in so far as it is subject to reason. That which specifies a human action as morally good or bad is whatever makes an action to be the kind of act that it is, and this is determined by the object of the act. The object of a moral act is that to which the action tends by its very nature.

Who said that indifferent act can be good or evil through circumstances?

Thomas Aquinas
Hence that which we have described as good in the doctrine of Thomas Aquinas, and as indifferent to the mind of Duns Scotus, must according to these theologians, be deemed nothing else than bad. The advocates of this opinion are one with Aquinas only in declaring that there are no indifferent deliberate acts.

What is a good sentence for indifferent?

Mr. Reynolds was indifferent to the subject. I was strong, active, indifferent to consequences. Similar magnetic poles are not merely indifferent to each other, but exhibit actual repulsion.

What does good bad or indifferent mean?

Having a positive, negative, or null effect. Often used to pose a question about something, especially in the titles of articles.

What makes a human act morally good or bad?

For a human act to be morally good the agent or doer must have a good intention — he must want to accomplish something that is good in one way or another. Some actions, like blasphemy and stealing, are always wrong and no purpose, no matter how noble, can make them good. Other actions may be either good or bad, depending on why we do them.

Can the most noble intention make an intrinsically evil action a good action?

The most noble intention cannot make an intrinsically evil action a good action. Thus, the bombings and killings perpetrated by terrorists in order to change some form of government are still murder. Stealing from the rich in order to help the poor a la Robin Hood is still stealing.

Can circumstances change the moral quality of an act?

Circumstances “of themselves cannot change the moral quality of acts themselves; they can make neither good nor right an action that is in itself evil” ( Ibid .). “A morally good act requires the goodness of the object, of the end, and of the circumstances together” ( Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1755).

How do circumstances make an otherwise good action evil?

Circumstances can make an otherwise good action evil, as when a soldier deliberately goes to sleep. They can increase the guilt, as when a girl lies to her mother; or minimize the guilt, as an unpremeditated lie in order to get out of an embarrassing situation.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90VRcMRcHi8