Table of Contents
What is the criticism of Plato?
Platonic criticism, literary criticism based on the philosophical writings of Plato, especially his views on art expressed in Phaedrus, Ion, and the Republic. Art, therefore, was no more than an imitation of an imitation and of value only insofar as it directed the soul toward the real—i.e., Truth, Beauty, or the Good.
Who criticized Plato’s Republic?
Robert Mayhew The first five chapters of the second book of Aristotle’s Politics contain a series of criticisms levelled against Plato’s Republic.
What are the problems with Plato’s idea of a philosopher king?
The biggest problem with Plato’s idea of a philosopher king has always been a simple and basic one: Who gets to determine who the philosopher kings are, or, what amounts to almost the same question: Who gets to determine the criteria by which we select the philosopher kings?
Should only philosophers be kings according to Aristotle?
Aristotle’s criticism of Plato’s theoretic propoSltlOn that only philosophers should be kings probably arose from his insight that a good ruler “should avoid impossibilities”8) and impracticabilities, such as Plato had indeed advocated in his Repllblic.
Why should we honor Aristotle instead of Plato?
We should honor Aristotle, who slightly altered Plato’sstatement and made bis advice truer. Aristotle said that it was not merely unnecessary for a king to be a philosopher, but even distinct disadvantage. What a king should do was1:0 listen to and take the advice oftrue philosophers.
What is ‘philosopher king’?
‘Philosopher king’, the idea according to which the best form of government is that in which philosophers rule. The ideal of a philosopher king was born in Plato’s dialogue ‘Republic’ as part of the vision of a just city. It was influential in the Roman Empire and was even revived in European political thought in the age of absolutist monarchs.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RH_6zqgPYpI